4 Reasons Why Pro-Infirmis' Campaign Is Problematic

4 Reasons Why Pro-Infirmis' Campaign Is Problematic

Recently, Swiss disability advocacy organization Pro Infirmis created a campaign to help raise awareness on International Day of Persons with Disabilities. The organization picked five people to participate in the campaign.

1. Athlete Urs Kolly, who lost part of his right leg.

2. Miss Handicap 2010’s Jasmine Rechsteiner, who has kyphoscoliosis (deformation of the spine).

3. Actor Erwin Alijukić, who has brittle bone disease.

4. Radio host and film critic, Alex Oberholzer, who has polio.

5. Blogger Nadja Schmid, who has ongenital spinal muscular atrophy

In short, the video titled “Because who is perfect?”, showed a designer taking measurements of the five candidates and making mannequins that mirrored their bodies. The custom mannequins were dressed and displayed on the store front of Zurich’s main street, Bahnhofstrasse, which is known as the world’s most expensive retail strip. Then, the video filmed the surprised reactions of people passing by.

Heartwarming quotes like: “It is special to see yourself like this. When you usually can’t look at yourself in the mirror”, reminds me of Dove’s viral real beauty sketch campaign on self esteem. It’s also riding on the plus size and colour mannequin trend that’s been going around lately as well. It is a beautiful video and does the job of bringing awareness and representing a demographic that’s often excluded. However, as much as I do believe the good intentions behind this, I’ve noticed a few things that can be problematic.

1. The "Special Occasion" Mannequin

candidates

As far as representing a group of people, this shouldn't be a one time thing. They shouldn't be seen as the "special ocassion" mannequins that gets pulled out just for International Day of Persons with Disabilities. These people live like this their whole lives, which leads me to my second point...

2. It Doesn't Stop at Changing the Mannequin

Mannequins are seen as representations of ourselves when we shop, hence that's why they're there. But, how many times have you tried on something just to realize they don't fit you like how they fit on the mannequin? What I'm saying is, this is more than a representation issue.

3. Isolating A Demographic

candidate

Personally, I would've liked to see a mix of custom mannequins and the original mannequins together, all dressed up in the store front. I find it unneccesary to segregate the two because we do all exist together. What we want to do is integrate people with disabilities into our society, not isolate them.

4. Not-So-Hidden Advertisements

modissa

The glossy store sign Modissa was shot so many times, the campaign could've passed as a commercial which was what I literally thought before I read about the organization. Plus, this video suspiciously went viral during holiday shopping season...

 

By Stephanie Wu
Dec 5, 2013 @ 15:33

Comments

Content Stream

  • 7 hours 7 min agoChantilly Post52 views
    The Halifax born journalist turned DJ has embarked his Sucker For Punishment tour and is in the full swing of things. Ryan Hemsworth is just finishing up in Canada and then off to the states for the last chunk of the tour. We got a chance to speak over the phone as he was chilling out in Toronto getting over the cold.  We talked touring essentials, Osheaga, and his Secret Songs platform where he shares all his favourite tunes. IX Daily: How’s the tour life going?  Ryan Hemsworth...
  • 7 hours 36 min agoEmilie Croning6 views
    Who says balloon sculptures are reserved for the average birthday party clown?  After being approached by Garage Magazine, Robert Moy, founder of The Brooklyn Balloon Company, demonstrated his talent by recreating Keith Haring's well known Five Dancing Guys (1987). A project that took 2 days and 150 black balloons. Bringing a more modern take on balloon art, Moy says:  "I’ve always been a big fan of Keith Haring and thought his work would translate well using balloons. [...]...
  • 7 hours 55 min agoJessica Canje23 views
    Remember this prison training scene from Dark Night Rises?   You can catch something similar of that nature in the new music video Skrillex just released: Nabil Elderkin has directed some amazing and noteworthy music videos in the past. From Lana Del Rey’s "Ultraviolence" video to the "Mercy" music video by GOOD music (amongst many others). Nabil has managed to woo us with his wide range of experiences with different artists. Skrillex has chosen Nabil Elderkin to direct the...
  • 7 hours 55 min agoSarah Isa7 views
    If you haven't done so yet, get familiar with Detroit soul singer JMSN. After releasing his first album last year titled †Priscilla†, JMSN gives us a little preview of his new album with "Street Sweeper (Remix)" featuring rapper Freddie Gibbs. The Michigan-singer's new project, JMSN (Blue Album), is set for an early release on December 19th and from what we've heard so far, we cannot wait! Always coming out with intense and heartfelt tracks, this new album will...
  • 8 hours 43 min agoFirdaus Dawood27 views
    Ruane Maurice, whose single ‘Nomenclature’ dropped in August, debuted a simple but relentlessly effective music video for the track yesterday morning and all I could think of as I played it over and over today was this: When I was 12, my sisters left for the summer to backpack through France together. Not only was I pissed that I was missing this adventure, but by the time they got back, all they’d brought me was a cassette tape full of old school French hip hop, the dark, sultry kind you can’t...
  • Nov 24, 2014 @ 11:16Amanda Bell-lloch1 view
    A few days ago, a video emerged from the dark corners of the Internet that left us in shock and awe. "Sturmgruppe", directed by Eli Roth (star of Inglourious Basterds), said that "the footage is so sick, it's been locked in a vault for a year" Well, I have a couple of things to say about this video.  First of all, the video itself is a slow motion satanic mess, where Marilyn Manson (who denied his involvement on the making of the actual scene), sits nonchalantly at a table while...
  • Nov 24, 2014 @ 11:11Zoe Chou21 views
    If you own a TV and cared to watch the AMAs last night, you probably got a glimpse into the state of popular American music today. Whether it be good or bad, that’s for you to decide. What mostly caught my interest was the category for Best New Artist: Bastille vs. Lorde vs. Imagine Dragons vs. Iggy Azalea vs. Sam Smith (my choice). Ultimately, it went to Imagine Dragons. On that note, I thought it was time to share some names catching wind in underground/blog/alternative/hipster/Soundcloud/...
  • Nov 24, 2014 @ 11:00Dana Ewachow190 views
    Delusional comments always pop up in conversations about catcalling: “Yeah, but it wouldn’t happen if [insert excuse for catcaller here]”. These stubborn swamp-donkeys tend to blame the woman for showing too much skin or for having the audacity of being attractive. When it’s not being pointed out that she would never be followed if she was wearing a parka (which I know from personal experience is NOT true), people call her too sensitive. He’s just saying “hi”. He called you beautiful, what’s...
More articles