4 Reasons Why Pro-Infirmis' Campaign Is Problematic

4 Reasons Why Pro-Infirmis' Campaign Is Problematic

Recently, Swiss disability advocacy organization Pro Infirmis created a campaign to help raise awareness on International Day of Persons with Disabilities. The organization picked five people to participate in the campaign.

1. Athlete Urs Kolly, who lost part of his right leg.

2. Miss Handicap 2010’s Jasmine Rechsteiner, who has kyphoscoliosis (deformation of the spine).

3. Actor Erwin Alijukić, who has brittle bone disease.

4. Radio host and film critic, Alex Oberholzer, who has polio.

5. Blogger Nadja Schmid, who has ongenital spinal muscular atrophy

In short, the video titled “Because who is perfect?”, showed a designer taking measurements of the five candidates and making mannequins that mirrored their bodies. The custom mannequins were dressed and displayed on the store front of Zurich’s main street, Bahnhofstrasse, which is known as the world’s most expensive retail strip. Then, the video filmed the surprised reactions of people passing by.

Heartwarming quotes like: “It is special to see yourself like this. When you usually can’t look at yourself in the mirror”, reminds me of Dove’s viral real beauty sketch campaign on self esteem. It’s also riding on the plus size and colour mannequin trend that’s been going around lately as well. It is a beautiful video and does the job of bringing awareness and representing a demographic that’s often excluded. However, as much as I do believe the good intentions behind this, I’ve noticed a few things that can be problematic.

1. The "Special Occasion" Mannequin

candidates

As far as representing a group of people, this shouldn't be a one time thing. They shouldn't be seen as the "special ocassion" mannequins that gets pulled out just for International Day of Persons with Disabilities. These people live like this their whole lives, which leads me to my second point...

2. It Doesn't Stop at Changing the Mannequin

Mannequins are seen as representations of ourselves when we shop, hence that's why they're there. But, how many times have you tried on something just to realize they don't fit you like how they fit on the mannequin? What I'm saying is, this is more than a representation issue.

3. Isolating A Demographic

candidate

Personally, I would've liked to see a mix of custom mannequins and the original mannequins together, all dressed up in the store front. I find it unneccesary to segregate the two because we do all exist together. What we want to do is integrate people with disabilities into our society, not isolate them.

4. Not-So-Hidden Advertisements

modissa

The glossy store sign Modissa was shot so many times, the campaign could've passed as a commercial which was what I literally thought before I read about the organization. Plus, this video suspiciously went viral during holiday shopping season...

 

By Stephanie Wu
Dec 5, 2013 @ 15:33

Comments

Content Stream

  • 1 hour 30 min agoMaria Magdeleina Lotfi9 views
    There is always something problematic about music video awards. Take for instance MTV’s Video Music Awards. This ceremony used to be about rewarding artists and directors for their hard work put into creating a clip of quality. People forget nowadays about the artistry of a music video. The focus isn’t on music videos per say, but mostly on the performances that will be held during the night of the show, on the host, on who’s the best dressed, or the worst dressed, and on celebrities’ behaviour...
  • 1 hour 46 min agoDana Ewachow22 views
    I want to make something really clear: Vin Diesel is amazing. He’s an action star and proud D&D nerd. He’s the voice of the Iron Giant. He’s Groot, for god’s sake. It’s eye-opening to read and watch his interviews, especially his latest one where he describes his rough time dealing with his friend and co-star Paul Walker unexpectedly dying. For someone who’s known for portraying the big burly action star/robot/tree, it’s startling to see him admit how vulnerable he was. People probably...
  • 2 hours 55 min agoIX Staff8 views
    Singer, songwriter, producer, artist and nobleman Rudi Zygadlo has seemingly endless auditory tricks up his sleeve. We first linked up with him for our dubstep compilation back in 2010. Since then, he’s been remixing and producing for huge artists and releasing original tunes on his own. “Slow Carz” is what we envision real pop music should be. Emotional, production-heavy, but still raw. Headphone material for you and your lover to daisy chain to.  Additional production/mixing by William...
  • 3 hours 8 sec agoIX Staff9 views
    The well-traveled LA based five piece band FOOL’S GOLD have released the official music video for their new single “I’m in Love,” along with announcing their new album Flying Lessons, out on April 18th (Record Store Day) via ORG Music.Flying Lessons is the follow-up album to 2011’s Leave No Trace, which saw a multitude of positive reviews from online sources, including us. Fool’s Gold has spent much of the past few years on the road, including...
  • 3 hours 8 min agoIX Staff19 views
    Sacramento might be one of the sunniest cities in the country, but for some, it seems as if they're engulfed in a smog of crime and violence. Discrimination, police sirens and gun shots mask the voices of those trying to fight for what's right, while others thank a higher power for making it through another day. For those who acknowledge the system that is Sactown, and all of its hardships, will no doubt admire the efforts of Chuuwee and JR & PH7, for their latest video, "Meadowview Morning...
  • Mar 27, 2015 @ 01:27Savannah Scott19 views
    Rudsak would be the highlight of World Mastercard Fashion Week day 4, closing the day with the typical high-quality Canadian winter wear they've been putting out for years. It was less about the accessories this season and more about layering, which they did with greens, tans and browns. All photos courtesy of WMCFW.  Where in the world is Carmen San Diego? Check out the rest of the highlights from the show below, and follow our coverage of Toronto's fashion week on our Twitter and...
  • Mar 26, 2015 @ 11:51Savannah Scott37 views
    Atelier Wonder stole the show yesterday, opening day 3 of Toronto's fashion week with a Blade Runner-inspired line that had everyone pointing and gasping uncontrollably. Let's be real, Fashion Week is not without it's let downs. When you sit down at a show and all that's sent down the runway is black, boring shapes seen years before, it's really hard not to be bummed. The new collection, entitled Replicant, brought in the colour and textures that we were all waiting for.  We wore Atelier...
  • Mar 26, 2015 @ 09:22IX Staff28 views
    Elektrisk Gønner sparked our curiosity. We're talking about a sassy french-danish band now based in Brooklyn, NY and currently recording their second album in NYC. They released a first EP and album, featuring the danish artist MØ, and toured the world with hectic shows all over the place.    Their single “Uknowhatiwant” music video generated over 1 million views online, and was featured on the TV series Lost Girl (SciFi) and Girls (HBO). Check out the NSFW music...
More articles