4 Reasons Why Pro-Infirmis' Campaign Is Problematic

4 Reasons Why Pro-Infirmis' Campaign Is Problematic

Recently, Swiss disability advocacy organization Pro Infirmis created a campaign to help raise awareness on International Day of Persons with Disabilities. The organization picked five people to participate in the campaign.

1. Athlete Urs Kolly, who lost part of his right leg.

2. Miss Handicap 2010’s Jasmine Rechsteiner, who has kyphoscoliosis (deformation of the spine).

3. Actor Erwin Alijukić, who has brittle bone disease.

4. Radio host and film critic, Alex Oberholzer, who has polio.

5. Blogger Nadja Schmid, who has ongenital spinal muscular atrophy

In short, the video titled “Because who is perfect?”, showed a designer taking measurements of the five candidates and making mannequins that mirrored their bodies. The custom mannequins were dressed and displayed on the store front of Zurich’s main street, Bahnhofstrasse, which is known as the world’s most expensive retail strip. Then, the video filmed the surprised reactions of people passing by.

Heartwarming quotes like: “It is special to see yourself like this. When you usually can’t look at yourself in the mirror”, reminds me of Dove’s viral real beauty sketch campaign on self esteem. It’s also riding on the plus size and colour mannequin trend that’s been going around lately as well. It is a beautiful video and does the job of bringing awareness and representing a demographic that’s often excluded. However, as much as I do believe the good intentions behind this, I’ve noticed a few things that can be problematic.

1. The "Special Occasion" Mannequin

candidates

As far as representing a group of people, this shouldn't be a one time thing. They shouldn't be seen as the "special ocassion" mannequins that gets pulled out just for International Day of Persons with Disabilities. These people live like this their whole lives, which leads me to my second point...

2. It Doesn't Stop at Changing the Mannequin

Mannequins are seen as representations of ourselves when we shop, hence that's why they're there. But, how many times have you tried on something just to realize they don't fit you like how they fit on the mannequin? What I'm saying is, this is more than a representation issue.

3. Isolating A Demographic

candidate

Personally, I would've liked to see a mix of custom mannequins and the original mannequins together, all dressed up in the store front. I find it unneccesary to segregate the two because we do all exist together. What we want to do is integrate people with disabilities into our society, not isolate them.

4. Not-So-Hidden Advertisements

modissa

The glossy store sign Modissa was shot so many times, the campaign could've passed as a commercial which was what I literally thought before I read about the organization. Plus, this video suspiciously went viral during holiday shopping season...

 

By Stephanie Wu
Dec 5, 2013 @ 15:33

Comments

Content Stream

  • 8 hours 3 min agoNick Watts10 views
    One of Never Say Die’s firm favourites releases his new EP on October 27th. Spanning six tracks in length, “The End” is a seriously well-produced body of work from the young Belgian. Having also designed the artwork for this EP, dubstep boss Eptic says of its theme, 'The End’ is a mix of music that I’m known for, accompanied by styles that before this day have never left my studio. In this case, “the end” stands for a new beginning." It certainly covers a lot of musical ground – whether it’s...
  • 8 hours 12 min agoCyncia Sanon20 views
    If you don't know by now, ILoveMakonnen is a ATL hip hop artist who's name is buzzing right now. After Drake's co-sign, the youngin just blew up... Like, really. ILoveMakonnen was locally known with songs like "Molly" and "Tuesday" but as soon as Drake remixed "Tuesday" everybody "loved" Makonnen. This simple video shows how everybody has their own way to turn up on a Tuesday. And of course, we can see ILoveMakonnen and Drake turning up, in a club...on a Tuesday. Now, let's be honest, this...
  • 8 hours 24 min agoAnthony Muzonzini7 views
    The music industry has just received another blow amidst reports that no album released this year is set to sell more than 1 million copies. This will be the first time that this has happened every since records began in 1976. No album is even close at the moment with Beyonce's self-titled album being the closest along with Lorde's "Pure Heroine", but neither of these titles have reached the 800,000 mark yet and their sales tapered off months ago. There is one exception though. The...
  • 8 hours 35 min agoCyncia Sanon164 views
    OMG! Again, OMG! I just love Wang's collection for H&M. Every items of the women AND men collection bring tears to my eyes... seriously. Everything is black, sporty and fashionably urban. Lycra, leather and breathable fabrics: you're ready for a marathon in Manhattan. There's crop tops, leather pants, sports bra, parkas, jackets, beanies, tank tops, dresses, sweatshirts, gloves, socks, slippers, boots, leggings, sneakers, shorts, bikinis, belts, yoga mats, duffle bags, backpacks, water...
  • 9 hours 4 min agoMelissa Nudo57 views
    I'd like to begin this post by saying how fortunate single women of 2014 are to have something like Tinder to help them find the next guy that's going to finger them in the back seat of their Volkswagon and never call them again. I had to learn this the hard way.  I'm happy to say that I've been with my boyfriend for 3-ish years. He loves me for the weirdo that I am, but you know this already. That being said, I enjoy living vicariously through my single friends. For Instance, I've...
  • 9 hours 4 min agoChantilly Post12 views
    Ryan Hemsworth's self-proclaimed happysad (all one word) music is brilliant in all kinds of ways on his new album Alone for the First Time available November 4th on Secret Songs and Last Gang.  Following the release of the Snow In Newark video shot in Nepal over the course of a week, the video along with the album is an extremely personalized view on Hemsworth and his feelings with current music and just "finding something different." The album has collaborations with The GTW, Alex G and...
  • 9 hours 15 min agoDana Ewachow72 views
    Of course there are tons of opinions about Gamergate from journalists, game developers, and people who just want to sit on their couch and play until their thumbs cramp. Some of the voices are in favour of the "movement", claiming that the whole point is about the video game industry lacking ethics in journalism. The mythos of Gamergate is said to have begun by Zoe Quinn’s ex-boyfriend who released information that Quinn dated a writer for Kotaku, which is why her game got a good review....
  • 9 hours 29 min agoNikki Noborikawa 11 views
    Dillon Francis’ debut album Money Sucks, Friends Rule, is set to drop October 28th, and we got to attend his album release party in LA to celebrate. The circus themed event was held at the intimate Sonos Studios and included clowns, sword swallowers, jugglers, balloon artists, and contortionists. So let’s just say that Dillon did NOT hold back! Dillon released a few songs prior to the album starting with “Get Low” featuring DJ Snake, “Set Me Free” with Martin Garrix, “I Can’t Take It” and “We...
More articles