4 Reasons Why Pro-Infirmis' Campaign Is Problematic

4 Reasons Why Pro-Infirmis' Campaign Is Problematic

Recently, Swiss disability advocacy organization Pro Infirmis created a campaign to help raise awareness on International Day of Persons with Disabilities. The organization picked five people to participate in the campaign.

1. Athlete Urs Kolly, who lost part of his right leg.

2. Miss Handicap 2010’s Jasmine Rechsteiner, who has kyphoscoliosis (deformation of the spine).

3. Actor Erwin Alijukić, who has brittle bone disease.

4. Radio host and film critic, Alex Oberholzer, who has polio.

5. Blogger Nadja Schmid, who has ongenital spinal muscular atrophy

In short, the video titled “Because who is perfect?”, showed a designer taking measurements of the five candidates and making mannequins that mirrored their bodies. The custom mannequins were dressed and displayed on the store front of Zurich’s main street, Bahnhofstrasse, which is known as the world’s most expensive retail strip. Then, the video filmed the surprised reactions of people passing by.

Heartwarming quotes like: “It is special to see yourself like this. When you usually can’t look at yourself in the mirror”, reminds me of Dove’s viral real beauty sketch campaign on self esteem. It’s also riding on the plus size and colour mannequin trend that’s been going around lately as well. It is a beautiful video and does the job of bringing awareness and representing a demographic that’s often excluded. However, as much as I do believe the good intentions behind this, I’ve noticed a few things that can be problematic.

1. The "Special Occasion" Mannequin

candidates

As far as representing a group of people, this shouldn't be a one time thing. They shouldn't be seen as the "special ocassion" mannequins that gets pulled out just for International Day of Persons with Disabilities. These people live like this their whole lives, which leads me to my second point...

2. It Doesn't Stop at Changing the Mannequin

Mannequins are seen as representations of ourselves when we shop, hence that's why they're there. But, how many times have you tried on something just to realize they don't fit you like how they fit on the mannequin? What I'm saying is, this is more than a representation issue.

3. Isolating A Demographic

candidate

Personally, I would've liked to see a mix of custom mannequins and the original mannequins together, all dressed up in the store front. I find it unneccesary to segregate the two because we do all exist together. What we want to do is integrate people with disabilities into our society, not isolate them.

4. Not-So-Hidden Advertisements

modissa

The glossy store sign Modissa was shot so many times, the campaign could've passed as a commercial which was what I literally thought before I read about the organization. Plus, this video suspiciously went viral during holiday shopping season...

 

By Stephanie Wu
Dec 5, 2013 @ 15:33

Comments

Content Stream

  • Jan 29, 2015 @ 14:06Alexandra Delaney-Szulc68 views
    One of the biggest news stories at the start of 2015, was the nation-wide Target closures, which was a shock to some, and inevitable to others.  This was a case study on how difficult it is to break into the Canadian market, without considering Canadian consumer interests, and the way we shop.  Successful Japanese clothing retailers Uniqlo are making a go of it.  Their stores feature a full range of men’s, women’s and children’s items, and athletes like tennis star...
  • Jan 29, 2015 @ 12:54Angela Kara51 views
    People who are fortunate enough to be living in our modern society with their basic human rights met. The right to shelter, food, education...have very few concerns. There is food on the dinner table, and if you blow all your student loan money on partying you can just take out another. It seems logical that we should have the right to privacy. Privacy on the Internet, when texting, while walking down the street. You don't. You have no right to privacy. But hey! When you already have so much...
  • Jan 29, 2015 @ 12:10Melissa Nudo203 views
    I feel like I am entitled to call the readers of this ''fine'' article horrible because I'm horrible and it takes one to know one. Today's post is about honesty because we're going to be very honest with ourselves about our guilty or perhaps not-so-guilty pleasures... The same way I can admit that ''Girls'' is a show about every single annoying bitch you've ever known in your life condensed into 4 white girls but you can't stop watching because, I mean; I've gotten this far already so......
  • Jan 29, 2015 @ 11:38IX Staff11 views
    GFOTY IS A WAY OF LIFE. YOU CAN’T JUST EARN HER STATUS, YOU HAVE TO FULLY IMMERSE YOURSELF IN IT. YOU NEED TO HAVE BROWN HAIR AND BLUE EYES – YOU NEED TO BE 169CM TALL AND YOU NEED TO LOSE SOME WEIGHT. YOU NEED SEVERAL HOT MEN TO BE CRAWLING AT YOUR FEET  24/7  AND IF YOU CANT ACHIEVE THAT THEN YOU CAN NEVER BECOME A GFOTY. YOU’RE NOT EVEN ALLOWED TO BE HER FAN.  That is how the e-mail described what you're about to experience. You can only imagine that we couldn't hold back from...
  • Jan 29, 2015 @ 11:20IX Staff30 views
    We've recently covered Phoebe Ryan's eclectic cover of R. Kelly's "Ignition" mashed-up with Miguel's "Do You" and couldn't get enough of it. As per luck, Ms. Ryan has finally released an original song for everyone to enjoy titled "Mine". Stream below:  This Scandinavian pop artist has a sweet aura to her songs that is so enchanting, you won't be able to hit stop once you start playing her tunes.  Read more about Phoebe Ryan here. 
  • Jan 29, 2015 @ 11:02IX Staff14 views
    Hailing from Washington DC, Royal is a producer/song writer who teamed up with an eclectic bunch of creative people to put together a 5-track EP called CYCLES that was released earlier this week. Each track stands on its own, but the whole thing sorta comes together quite nicely. They dub this music as "conscious-pop" and we couldn't agree more.  Press play, and download the whole thing for free right here:   Blaise Railey and Lauren Engel were behind the visuals of this...
  • Jan 28, 2015 @ 16:46IX Staff3,518 views
    We recently sat down with Mother Mother to get to know them a bit better through an IXclusive interview. This Canadian vocal harmony indie rock band dropped heir most anticipated album last november, titled Very Good Bad Thing.  We got the chance to figure out 10 things we probably didn't know about them in the first place. Check out the video before anyone else, above.   Check out the time we got a private studio tour: click here Read our IXclusive...
  • Jan 28, 2015 @ 11:00IX Staff54 views
    Half-Truth is the pop-song-oriented project of a Montreal songwriter/producer/dj who has worked with, produced and remixed countless artists locally and south of the border. We've previously covered his remix for a Brooke Williams track, and today we bring to you the Premiere of his brand new EP. The EP is cleverly titled Hap Felt Thru, which is an anagram of “Half Truth EP”, loosely inspired by Brian Eno and the Talking Heads’ Kings Lead Hat, which was an anagram of Talking...
More articles